Rotec AI

Tools

Bearing SelectorPick the right bearing, step by stepVerify a BearingLife, safety factor and fitsLoad CalculatorLoads from your machineWorked templatesFan, gear and shaft load templatesCross-ReferenceSame size from other makersBearing AutopsyNewUpload a photo, get the likely causesFailure AnalysisRead damage, find the causeLubricationGreases, oils, cleanliness, oil lifeEquipment AnatomyMotors, pumps, fans, gearboxesFAQ and quick checksSearch the basics in plain languageFind a DistributorSuppliers by brand and city

Learn

Free calculatorsLife, grease, oil, loads and moreFind a bearingSize, rating and equivalents by designationFailure modesDamage types, causes and fixesKnowledge libraryLubrication and reliability articlesBearings by machineMotors, pumps, mills, kilns and moreHow-to guidesBearing life, grease, failures, numbersField casesFailure investigations and monitoring cases (licence)Lubrication guidesGreases, oil systems, oil life and costQuick answersPlain-language answers to common questions

More

PricingPartnershipsContact
Reading failed bearings

Loose fits, fretting and ring creep: reading the shaft seat and bore

Brown dust, polished bands and axial scoring on a seat mean the ring has been moving on it. The same signs on the bearing and the shaft tell one story.

What the movement leaves behind

When a ring moves relative to its seat, two things can happen. Small relative movement produces fretting corrosion: reddish brown oxide and dull pitted patches. Continuous turning produces creep: smooth polished surfaces and wear on the ring face. Both mean the seat is not holding the ring. Causes include a shaft that is too small, a housing bore that is too large, a worn or damaged seat, a ring forced to move because rolling elements stopped turning, or foreign material trapped between ring and seat.

Fretting corrosion on the inner ring bore: interference too light for the load.
Fretting corrosion on the inner ring bore: interference too light for the load.

Fretting corrosion on the outside diameter of a ring.
Fretting corrosion on the outside diameter of a ring.

Creep: smooth, polished outside diameter and ring face where the ring turned in the housing.
Creep: smooth, polished outside diameter and ring face where the ring turned in the housing.

Creep on an inner ring bore.
Creep on an inner ring bore.

The opposite problem

Too much interference is also visible. Scuffing on the bore surface and a ring that is hard to remove point to an excessive interference fit, which also takes up internal clearance and runs hot.

Scuffing on an inner ring bore from excessive interference with the shaft.
Scuffing on an inner ring bore from excessive interference with the shaft.

Field photographs: bearing and its shaft seat

The two field photographs below are shown as examples of what to look for. The reading is ours from the pictures alone and should be confirmed with measurements on the real parts.

Shaft seat next to a shoulder: axial scoring over the seat and brown fretting-like patches towards the right. The seat has been rubbed rather than simply loaded.
Shaft seat next to a shoulder: axial scoring over the seat and brown fretting-like patches towards the right. The seat has been rubbed rather than simply loaded.

A deep groove ball bearing with a bright, shiny bore and black grease. A bore polished like this is what a ring turning on its shaft leaves behind.
A deep groove ball bearing with a bright, shiny bore and black grease. A bore polished like this is what a ring turning on its shaft leaves behind.

Takeaway. A brown or polished seat is the symptom. The question for the repair is why the interference was lost: wrong tolerance, worn seat, heavy unbalanced load or poor assembly.
Put it to work in the tool

Related reading

Nine damage typesReading spall patterns on roller bearing racewaysOverheating and running dryDents on the racewayHandling and installation damageFractures, impact load and the rare real manufacturing defect
All knowledge articlesBearing failure modesGrease selector