Bearing materials: steels, heat treatment and ceramics compared
For most duties the standard 100Cr6 steel is right. Change the material only when a specific problem calls for it: heat, dirty lubricant, shock, sliding, corrosion, dry running or electric current. The tables below show what each option is good at, compared with the standard steel.
How the materials compare
Each row is scored against the standard bearing steel, 100Cr6 martensitic (the reference). A plus is better, an equals sign is the same, and a minus is worse. Scores are qualitative and the price column is only a guide, because real prices depend on the product and the quantity.
Standard solutions
| Material and heat treatment | Fatigue | Thermal influences | Sliding (slippage) load | Mechanical shock | Particle overrolling | Corrosion | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100Cr6, martensitic, class SN (reference 1) | = | − | = | = | = | = | Reference |
| 100Cr6, martensitic, class S0 (reference 2) | = | = | = | = | = | = | Reference |
| 100Cr6, martensitic, class S1 | = | + | + | − | −− | − | Same |
| 100Cr6, bainitic, class S1 | + | + | + | + | + | − | Same |
| St4 low-carbon steel, case hardened | − | − | = | = | = | = | Same |
| 100CrMnSi6-4, modified martensitic | + | = | = | = | + | = | Slightly higher |
| 100CrMnSi6-4, carbonitrided | ++ | − | + | = | ++ | − | Slightly higher |
| Case-hardening steel, case hardened | + | = | + | + | ++ | − | Slightly higher |
| Case-hardening steel, carbonitrided | ++ | = | + | + | ++ | − | Slightly higher |
| Nitrogen-alloyed corrosion-resistant steel (X30CrMoN15-1) | +++ | = to ++ | ++ | = | ++ | ++ | Higher |
| Corrosion-resistant case-hardened nitrogen steel | + | = | + | = | = | ++ | Slightly higher |
Special solutions
| Material and heat treatment | Fatigue | Thermal influences | Sliding (slippage) load | Mechanical shock | Particle overrolling | Corrosion | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100Cr6, martensitic, class SN (reference 1) | = | − | = | = | = | = | Reference |
| 100Cr6, martensitic, class S0 (reference 2) | = | = | = | = | = | = | Reference |
| M50 tool steel, martensitic | = | ++ | = | = | − | − | Higher |
| M50NiL, case hardened | ++ | ++ | ++ | ++ | + | − | Higher |
| Austenitic stainless, carburised | − | + | = | = | − | + | Higher |
| M50NiL, duplex hardened | ++ | ++ | ++ | ++ | ++ | − | Much higher |
| 32CrMoV13, nitrided | ++ | ++ | ++ | + | ++ | = | Slightly higher |
| Powder-metallurgy high-speed steel | +++ | +++ | ++ | ++ | +++ | = | Higher |
| Hard metal (cemented carbide, metallic binder) | ++ | +++ | +++ | = | +++ | +++ | Much higher |
| Silicon nitride Si3N4 (rolling elements) | + | +++ | ++ | = | = | ++ | Much higher |
| Zirconium oxide ZrO2 (rolling elements) | − | +++ | = | − | − | +++ | Higher |
| Symbol | Compared with the reference |
|---|---|
| +++ | Excellent |
| ++ | Significantly better |
| + | Better |
| = | Identical to the reference |
| − | Worse |
| −− | Significantly worse |
Through-hardened and standard steels
The everyday rolling bearing steels. 100Cr6 is hardened right through and tempered; the tempering temperature sets the stabilisation class (SN, S0, S1), which is how far above normal the ring keeps its size when hot. Bainitic hardening and low-carbon formed-part steel complete the family.
| Material | Hardness and temperature | Strengths | Limits | Typical uses |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100Cr6 martensitic, class SN | Hardness up to 64 HRC; to about +120 °C | Versatile, very hard, wear resistant, resists overrolling; best price and performance; available everywhere | Not for high temperature, heavy shock, sliding contact, lubricant starvation or corrosion | All bearing series |
| 100Cr6 martensitic, class S0 | Up to 62 HRC; over +150 °C | Same as SN, with size stability at higher temperature | Same limits as SN for shock, sliding, starvation and corrosion | All bearing series |
| 100Cr6 martensitic, class S1 | Up to 62 HRC; over +200 °C | Same as SN, stable at the highest standard temperature class | Lower resistance to shock and to particle overrolling than the reference | Small combustion engines; fan bearing supports in steel mills |
| 100Cr6 bainitic, class S1 | Up to 62 HRC; over +200 °C | Hard, wear resistant, very good overrolling resistance; compressive stresses in the surface zone make cracks much less likely even with surface damage | Not for corrosion or lubricant starvation | Roller bearings with high sliding contact; bucket wheel excavators; tram wheelsets |
| St4 low-carbon steel, case hardened | Up to 62 HRC; to about +120 °C | Universal for small parts; good formability; good price and performance in large volumes of formed parts | Comparatively soft core, so lower fatigue strength | Drawn-cup needle roller bearings; universal joints; motorcycle swing arms |
Case-hardened and carbonitrided steels
A hard surface over a tough core, or a surface with retained austenite. These are the steels for dirty oil, poor lubrication, shock loads and large bearings.
| Material | Hardness and temperature | Strengths | Limits | Typical uses |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100CrMnSi6-4, modified martensitic | Up to 65 HRC; about 15% retained austenite; to about +120 °C (higher for short periods) | High hardness and wear resistance; same fatigue strength in particle overrolling as carbonitrided 100Cr6 at a better price | High shock loads; sliding contact; corrosion | Steel production; passenger car gearboxes |
| 100CrMnSi6-4, carbonitrided | 66 HRC outer layer (62 + 4); more retained austenite | Much higher resistance to surface damage; longer life in poor lubrication and where contamination risk is high | High shock loads; corrosion | Hydraulic axial piston motor output shafts; construction and agricultural gearboxes |
| Case-hardening steel (17MnCr5, 17CrNiMo7-6), carburised and hardened | 64 HRC hard surface, tough core; to about +120 °C | Compressive residual stresses in the surface; higher fracture resistance under shock or surface damage; less crack growth from damage | Corrosion; temperature above +120 °C | Medium and large bearings: wind turbine main rotor bearings, heavy truck wheel bearings |
| Case-hardening steel, carbonitrided | Up to 65 HRC; to about +120 °C (higher for short periods) | Very high wear resistance; higher dynamic load carrying capacity in poor lubrication; resists particle overrolling | Corrosion | Steel rolling mill bearings; wind power gearboxes |
Corrosion-resistant steels
Where water, washdown, process media or weak acids would ruin a normal steel, and where a seal is costly or impossible.
| Material | Hardness and temperature | Strengths | Limits | Typical uses |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nitrogen-alloyed corrosion-resistant steel (X30CrMoN15-1), martensitic | Up to 62 HRC; to about +150 °C | High load capacity, high fatigue life, very good corrosion resistance; allows costly seals to be left out; works with media lubrication and dry running | Corrosion by strong acids | Machine tool spindles; process pumps |
| Corrosion-resistant case-hardened nitrogen steel | Up to 62 HRC hard surface, tough core; over +180 °C | Very good resistance to overrolling and to corrosion; suited to lubricant starvation, first lubrication and dry running | Strong acids | Bottle filling plant; inline skates |
| Austenitic stainless (X5CrNi18-10, AISI 304), carburised | Thin hard layer of about 58 HRC with tough core; rings over 300 mm and loads over 2,000 MPa | Non-magnetic; excellent resistance to media; no shielding needed | Low hardness against martensitic steels, so lower fatigue strength | Butterfly valve positioning; gimbal mountings |
High-temperature and aerospace steels
Tool steels and nitrided steels that keep hardness far above the limit of 100Cr6, with very high speeds and little cooling.
| Material | Hardness and temperature | Strengths | Limits | Typical uses |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| M50 tool steel, vacuum remelted, martensitic | Up to 64 HRC; +350 to +400 °C | Thermally stable with increased toughness; needs little cooling; prevents premature failure | Corrosion; extremely high centrifugal stresses | Aircraft engine main shaft bearings |
| M50NiL, case hardened | Surface up to 64 HRC; +350 to +400 °C; residual compressive stresses | Thermal stability with much higher toughness and fracture resistance; for very high speeds | Corrosion | Aircraft engine main shaft bearings at extreme speed |
| M50NiL, duplex hardened (carburised, hardened and nitrided) | Surface up to 70 HRC; +350 to +400 °C | Higher fracture resistance, very good wear resistance, very good tolerance of damage after particle overrolling | Corrosion | Aircraft engines at extreme speed |
| 32CrMoV13, nitrided | Up to 64 HRC; stable to +350 °C; nitriding depth over 0.6 mm; outside diameter up to about 160 mm | High fatigue strength above +150 °C; good overrolling resistance even with starvation; resists surface damage by particles and false brinelling | Size limited to about 160 mm outside diameter | Aircraft engine and other bearings under thermal load |
| Powder-metallurgy high-speed steel | Up to 66 HRC; heat resistant | High static and dynamic load capacity, wear and heat resistance; robust against brinelling, lubricant starvation and particle overrolling | Corrosive attack | Machine tool spindle bearings; engine components |
| Hard metal (cemented carbide with metallic binder) | Above 1,300 HV; components up to 400 mm; wide temperature swings | Very high heat resistance, modulus of elasticity, wear and corrosion resistance; non-magnetic; allows ambient media in place of oil lubrication; dry running | Size limit about 400 mm; cost | Ocean energy generation; pumps and compressors |
Ceramic rolling elements and hybrid bearings
Steel rings with ceramic balls or rollers. Ceramic is hard, light, non-magnetic and an electrical insulator, and it runs with very little friction.
| Material | Hardness and temperature | Strengths | Limits | Typical uses |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silicon nitride Si3N4, hot isostatically pressed | About 1,500 HV; very low density; usable to about +700 °C; used with steel rings | Hybrid bearings with much higher load capacity than ZrO2; with matched rings (nitrogen steel or carbonitrided) a much higher rating life even under high load; lower mass; very high speed; current insulation; less friction and longer grease life | Normally used only as rolling elements against steel rings; higher cost | Machine tool spindles; food industry |
| Zirconium oxide ZrO2 | About 1,400 HV; density between Si3N4 and steel; usable to about +600 °C; thermal expansion close to steel | Current insulation, wear resistance, lower friction; first lubrication; usually cheaper than Si3N4 | Contact pressures over 1,500 MPa; suited to low loads | Electric window motors in cars; food technology |
Which material for which problem
| Your problem | What to look at |
|---|---|
| Ordinary duty, normal temperature | 100Cr6 martensitic, class SN or S0: the reference, with the best price and availability |
| Operating temperature above +150 °C | Heat-stabilised rings (class S0 to S3 in the bearing number), then tool steels, nitrided 32CrMoV13 or ceramics above about +250 °C |
| Dirty oil or grease, particles in the lubricant | Carbonitrided steel or steel with retained austenite; a hybrid bearing is another route |
| Shock loads or surface damage risk | Case-hardened steel or bainitic steel: compressive stresses slow crack growth |
| Sliding or slippage (skidding rollers) | Bainitic, carbonitrided, duplex or nitrided steels, or ceramic rolling elements |
| Water, washdown or process media | Nitrogen-alloyed corrosion-resistant steels, or ceramic or hard-metal parts for the harshest media |
| Starvation or dry running | Corrosion-resistant nitrogen steel, hard metal, or a hybrid bearing |
| Current through the bearing (inverter drives) | Ceramic rolling elements (a hybrid bearing) or an insulated bearing; see the electrical damage pages |
| Very high speed | Hybrid bearings with ceramic balls, or tool steels, because the lower mass cuts centrifugal load |
| Non-magnetic duty | Austenitic stainless, hard metal or ceramic |
Questions
What do the SN, S0 and S1 classes mean?
They are heat-stabilisation classes for the rings. SN is the standard class for service to about +120 °C, S0 holds size up to about +150 °C and S1 up to about +200 °C. Higher classes (S2, S3) go to about +250 °C and +300 °C. A bearing run hotter than its class can grow and lose clearance.
When is a hybrid ceramic bearing worth the extra cost?
When you need very high speed, protection from electric current through the bearing, longer grease life or tolerance of poor lubrication. Ceramic balls or rollers are hard and light, run cooler and do not carry current. They cost more than an all-steel bearing.
Which steel is best when the lubricant is dirty?
Carbonitrided steels, and steels with controlled retained austenite, tolerate hard particles in the oil or grease better than the standard steel. Cleaning the lubricant and sealing better still comes first.
Can a corrosion-resistant steel replace seals?
In some wet or media-lubricated duties a nitrogen-alloyed corrosion-resistant steel allows seals to be left out, but it has limits in strong acids. Check the medium before you decide.